HomeAdvanced journalismBeyond basic fact-checking

Beyond basic fact-checking

In-Depth Fact-Checking - a MHM training article graphicFact-checking is a complex, evidence-based process which goes beyond simple verification, demanding critical thinking and contextual analysis.

The aim is to combat misinformation and promote informed decision-making.

This site already has a piece about the basics of fact-checking and adding context; this article is a combination of two former articles on the site which looked at fact-checking in more depth.

Why fact-checking matters

We live in a time when trust in information is constantly tested. Misinformation (false but unintentional) and disinformation (deliberately misleading content) make it harder to make informed decisions. Fortunately, fact-checking tools are more accessible than ever, but they have limits. Not every claim can be verified. Opinions, predictions, and intent fall outside its scope. The challenge is that anyone can share information, blurring the line between credible news and baseless claims.

The fact-checker’s mindset

A fact-checker’s mindset means thinking critically about information by:

  • Being sceptical and curious: Questioning claims instead of accepting them at face value.
  • Understanding context: Looking at the source, audience, and possible motivations behind the information.
  • Relying on evidence: Using credible sources and avoiding personal biases.
  • Acting ethically: Being fair and transparent about how information is verified.
  • Working together: Fact-checking is more effective when done collaboratively.

How fact-checking works

  1. Choosing what to fact-check
    • Prioritise claims that could have real-world impact.
    • Pay attention to statements from public figures and viral content.
    • Distinguish between deliberate lies and honest mistakes.
  2. Keeping records
    • Save original sources to prevent claims from disappearing.
    • Document the verification process for transparency.
  3. Research & verification
    • Use keyword searches, reverse image searches, and expert opinions.
    • Check geolocation and video analysis tools for visual claims.
    • Rely on reputable sources such as established news organisations, universities, and government agencies.
    • Be aware of the complexities of video verification and proper interviewing techniques.
  4. Analysing information
    • Assess the credibility of sources and strength of evidence.
    • Recognise how language can be used to mislead.
    • Accept that some claims have grey areas and can’t always be definitively fact-checked.
    • Understand the differences between misinformation, disinformation, and malinformation.
  5. Publishing & sharing findings
    • Present findings in a clear and accessible way.
    • Provide context to help readers understand why the fact-check matters.
    • Be transparent about the process and sources used.
    • Follow clear correction policies.
    • Know the difference between pre-publication and post-publication fact-checking.

The challenges of fact-checking

  • Speed of misinformation: False information spreads quickly, making it hard to keep up.
  • Complexity of truth: Some claims require deep analysis and careful wording.
  • Fact-checking misuse: It can be weaponised to silence opinions or push agendas.
  • Mental health impact: Fact-checkers often face exposure to disturbing content.
  • Digital security risks: Online harassment and cyber threats are real concerns.
  • Bias awareness: Fact-checkers must recognise and counteract their own biases.

Ethical guidelines for fact-checkers

  • Be transparent: Explain how fact-checks are conducted and what sources are used.
  • Stay impartial: Avoid personal biases and strive for objectivity.
  • Be accurate: Verify everything before publishing.
  • Take responsibility: Admit and correct mistakes when needed.
  • Prioritise safety: Protect personal security and mental well-being.

The future of fact-checking

Fact-checking is always evolving, adapting to new technologies and challenges. It requires teamwork from journalists, researchers, educators, and the audience. By strengthening media literacy and critical thinking, we can all play a role in ensuring society is better informed.


Related material

Lesson: Beyond basic fact-checking

Fact-checking and adding context

SIFT for fact-checking

Creating a fact-checking system

Media Helping Media
Media Helping Media
We use the Media Helping Media byline in two ways. 1) When an article is the result of collaborative journalism using original content submitted by members of the Media Helping Media (MHM) network and expanded upon by the MHM team so that it is no longer the work of one person. 2) When an article has been developed by adding further research and structure - sometimes with the help of AI - in order to expand on the original human-created content and with everything produced by AI being subjected to rigorous human fact-checking and quality control. Read more about our AI policy here.