HomeEthical ScenariosPrivacy protection - scenario

Privacy protection – scenario

Image by ioerror / Jacob Appelbaums released via Creative Commons CC BY-SA 2.0
Image by ioerror / Jacob Appelbaums released via Creative Commons CC BY-SA 2.0

In this scenario you are the editor of a news website. A duty editor adds an image to a news story that you feel is unnecessarily graphic. What do you do?

Overnight, news breaks of fighting in a foreign land. Raw footage is filed showing dead bodies.

Your duty editor takes a screen grab from the video for an image to use at the top of the story. The image shows a dead man. His clothing is distinctive. You can see the man’s face.

The picture is dramatic but also shocking. Do you:

  1. Use the image as a strong illustration of the story about what is taking place.
  2. Try to find another image that is less graphic and doesn’t show the man’s face.
  3. Edit out his features using a photo editor and publish.

Suggested action

It would be best to try to find another image that is less graphic and doesn’t show the man’s face.

We always need to consider carefully the editorial justification for portraying graphic material of human suffering, distress, and death.

There are almost no circumstances in which it is justified to show executions and very few circumstances in which it is justified to broadcast other scenes in which people are being killed.

We should also avoid the gratuitous use of close-ups of faces and serious injuries or other violent material.

We must also be global in our news values. If we have editorial rules that state that we don’t publish details of someone who has been killed until the family has been notified, then that rule has to be applied globally.

Those in the West who apply such rules to domestic coverage need to ensure that they are consistent when dealing with tragedies in far-flung countries.

The family of a dead person who can clearly be identified, but who is the victim of a killing thousands of miles away, is entitled to the same editorial standards we apply when the incident is on our doorstep.

David Brewer
David Brewerhttps://mediahelpingmedia.org/
David Brewer is the founder and editor of Media Helping Media. He has worked as a journalist and manager in print, broadcast, and online. David was the UK editor for the launch of BBC News Online, becoming the managing editor soon after. Later he was appointed managing editor of CNN.com International EMEA where he set out the editorial proposition, hired staff, and oversaw the launch. David was the managing editor for the launch of CNN Arabic in Dubai, and a launch consultant for Al Jazeera English in Qatar. David has spent many years delivering journalism training worldwide, mainly in transition and post-conflict countries. He is currently mentoring journalists and editors of refugee and exiled media online as well as helping train journalists in countries where the media is still developing.