HomeEthical ScenariosLegal threats - scenario

Legal threats – scenario

Real ale in front of a pub fire. Image by Media Helping Media released via Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0In this scenario a local newspaper reporter faces legal threats for a factual planning application report that lacked the applicant’s demanded “positive spin”.

A local newspaper reporter has been assigned the task of monitoring licensing applications.

Their job, as set out by the news editor, is to check the weekly list of new applications submitted to the local council, contact the licensing department to find out the details, and then write a report.

Such stories usually cover premises wanting temporary permission to serve alcohol, existing premises wanting to stay open longer, or premises applying for a change of use.

The articles are meant to be simple, public information reports written to a formula.

They typically set out what has been applied for, include why the application has been made, and explain how anyone with concerns can register them.

While going through the latest licensing applications the reporter finds that a local pub has applied for a licensing extension which would allow it to remain open until the early hours of the morning.

The reporter copies the exact wording of the application and adds the text to the article. They then walk past the pub to take an exterior photograph.

The proprietor sees the reporter taking the photograph and asks them what they are doing. The reporter explains, and asks the proprietor to confirm the opening hours extension application.

The proprietor says it’s to meet “local demand”. He then admits that there will be some objections to the plans, but urges the reporter to add some “positive spin” to the report and offers to buy them a pint and lunch in the pub.

The reporter rejects the kind offer of refreshments – as is the newspaper’s policy – and returns to the office where they write an article along the following lines (the name of the pub and location have been altered) …

The Jolly Boozer applies for a licence extension

The recently reopened Jolly Boozer on High Street, Sleepinghyde, wants to extend opening hours to 2am on Fridays and Saturdays and half midnight the rest of the week.

The pub’s proprietor says the change is aimed at meeting local demand.

Anyone concerned about the increase in opening hours has until Friday 21 March to make their representations.

The reporter then includes:

  • the details of the application taken from the local authority’s official listing
  • a quote from the proprietor about why they have applied for the extension
  • and a paragraph about the public’s right to response.

The article is checked by the news editor, signed off by the editor, and published.

The next day, after the newspaper is published, the proprietor of the pub contacts the editor threatening legal action and claiming that the reporter had been involved in “coaxing negative representations” to the licensing office.

The proprietor demands an end to the “negative campaigning” against his business and calls for an article to be published in the newspaper to include the “positive spin” he had given the reporter about the extension application.

The editor calls the reporter into her office. The reporter denies any coaxing or campaigning, and explains that they were simply following normal procedure using a format used by the newspaper for all planning applications.

The editor agrees and calls the proprietor back explaining that she is satisfied that the article is fair, accurate, and in line with normal procedure.

The proprietor is not happy and accuses the reporter of being involved in a personal crusade to attack the business and says the matter has now been passed on to the company’s lawyers.

What should the editor and reporter do?

Should they:

  1. Publish a new story including “positive spin” in line with the proprietor’s request while leaving out the part which explains how people can make “representations” against the pub’s licensing extension application.
  2. Take advice from the news organisation’s lawyers.
  3. Stand firm, refuse to be bullied, and reject the demand for a follow-up article.

Suggested answer

A mixture of options 2 and 3.

In any situation where you are threatened with legal action you should first talk to your line manager. You may also want to talk to the news organisation’s lawyers just to be sure. However, you will probably find that their advice is to refuse to be bullied.

In the case above the reporter has done nothing wrong. Their article is a straight piece of public information reporting. It follows a format used by the newspaper for many years. Those living close to the pub need to know what the pub is planning. They deserve the chance to make representations if they are unhappy. It is part of the role of a local news organisation to share such information.

There will often be those who try to limit media freedom for their own ends by making legal threats. Their hope is that the journalist will become frightened and comply with their demands. But you must never be influenced by demands for “positive spin” or by false accusations of “coaxing” or “campaigning”.

Always refer up and, if legal action is threatened you should seek advice from your news organisation’s lawyers.

 


David Brewer
David Brewerhttps://mediahelpingmedia.org/
David Brewer is the founder and editor of Media Helping Media. He has worked as a journalist and manager in print, broadcast, and online. David was the UK editor for the launch of BBC News Online, becoming the managing editor soon after. Later he was appointed managing editor of CNN.com International EMEA where he set out the editorial proposition, hired staff, and oversaw the launch. David was the managing editor for the launch of CNN Arabic in Dubai, and a launch consultant for Al Jazeera English in Qatar. David has spent many years delivering journalism training worldwide, mainly in transition and post-conflict countries. He is currently mentoring journalists and editors of refugee and exiled media online as well as helping train journalists in countries where the media is still developing.