HomeEthical ScenariosInterview integrity - scenario

Interview integrity – scenario

Image by Birdy released via Creative Commons CC BY 2.0
Image by Birdy released via Creative Commons CC BY 2.0

In this scenario, we look at how an award-winning journalist was faced with an ethical choice when asked to carry out an interview that tested her integrity.

The journalist is offered a top job at a national TV station, but soon after starting she discovers corruption in the media house.

The journalist is something of a maverick by nature but has uncovered some exclusive stories on corrupt practices involving mining companies and politicians in the past.

Eventually her work leads to an award as anti-corruption journalist of the year.

The TV station recruits the journalist to be the main presenter on its evening business programme.

The journalist is excited by the new job and is looking forward to bringing her award-winning investigative journalistic approach to the programme.

However, it transpires that the TV station has signed a secret contract with the minister in charge of ‘Industry and Development’. It’s worth 250,000 US dollars, and guarantees the minister at least 10 appearances on the programme during a 20-week run.

The journalist finds out about the contract, but has only just joined the TV station where she is earning three times as much as she did in her previous job.

Should she:

  1. Say nothing but strive to ask difficult questions to balance out any bias
  2. Raise her concerns with the producer of the programme and the TV station’s management and hope that they will at least acknowledge that any interview is paid for
  3. Resign immediately and say nothing about why
  4. Resign immediately and leak the story to the TV station’s main competitor

Suggested action

In the real example of this scenario the reporter resigned but said nothing. However tough the interview might be, the reputational risk to the reporter’s name as a journalist was considered to be more important than any other consideration.

Raising the concerns with the station management was pointless, since corruption works two ways. Leaking the story would have broken the terms of the reporter’s contract of employment.


Jaldeep Katwala
Jaldeep Katwala
Jaldeep Katwala is the director of the Sir Lenny Henry Centre for Media Diversity at Birmingham City University. Until December he was the operations lead for The Bristol Cable and is still one of its directors. Prior to this, he was the network manager for the Public Interest News Foundation where he convened a vibrant community of independent news providers around the UK. Jaldeep was a BBC radio and television reporter and worked as a producer for Channel 4 News and as a presenter and documentary maker for Radio Netherlands International. He also led the undergraduate journalism degree course at Bournemouth University. Jaldeep has worked in media development roles in Serbia, Nigeria, Haiti, the Democratic Republic of Congo, Papua New Guinea, Southeast Asia and South Sudan.