An investigative journalist has to encourage people to share information they had previously withheld. Here we set out the opportunities and challenges.
Note: The original article by Don Ray was written in American English. His work is republished here (with permission) in British English, which is the MHM house style.
There may be many reasons why someone will agree to open up to a reporter, and some will be beyond their control.
It’s worth taking time to try to figure out the motives of the person you want to interview before you start talking to them. It may help you get a better interview.
Why would someone want to talk to a journalist and what might be their motives for doing so?
The following tips are offered to try to help investigative journalists understand more about those they are interviewing.
Why would someone want to talk to a journalist?
- They don’t really want to, but it’s part of their job – they have to.
- They believe strongly in their cause.
- They want to get the facts right – to set the record straight.
- They’re outraged at something or someone.
- They want to defend someone else.
- Their ego is so big they can’t resist the exposure.
- They feel guilty and want to confess.
- They want to defend themselves against what others are saying or doing.
- They want to give the impression they’re not guilty.
- They’re deluded – they don’t realise how foolish they’ll look.
- They’re a sociopath and think they can con the journalist.
- They have a hidden agenda.
- They’re obedient and believe that journalists have some kind of authority.
- They think it’s just the right thing to do.
- They’re getting paid by someone to talk.
- They’re trying to divert the journalist’s attention from something.
- They’re punishing another journalist or news outlet.
- They hope the exposure will further their career or help their reputation.
What would motivate a person to talk to a journalist?
- They believe that the journalist really cares.
- They believe that the journalist really understands the story.
- They believe that the journalist is likely to agree with their point of view.
- They believe that the journalist will somehow pay them for the interview.
- They’re rewarding the journalist who is more persistent.
- They’re rewarding the journalist who hasn’t pestered them.
- They want to talk to a journalist of a particular race, sex, religion, university, etc.
- They co-operate with a journalist who isn’t of a particular race, religion, etc.
- They are impressed with the journalist’s patience.
- They believe that the journalist will be more accurate than the others.
- They believe that the journalist is somehow more sympathetic or empathic.
- They believe that the journalist is more experienced.
- They believe that the journalist is more trustworthy.
- The journalist came highly recommended.
- They’ve read, seen or heard the journalist’s work and like it.
- They believe the journalist is naïve and can somehow be fooled.
- They believe the journalist’s publication/programme will reach more people.
- They believe that the journalist is just plain nice.
- They like the anchors on the journalist’s newscast.
- They hope to start a romantic relationship with the journalist.
- They believe that the journalist might help them get a job as a reporter.
- They believe that the reporter might have information that could be helpful.
- They support the perceived editorial position of the publication/station/network.
The investigative journalist should look for the telltale signs of certain feelings, emotions or conditions that may play a part in someone’s decision to co-operate – such as gratitude, trust, responsibility, fear, guilt, greed, curiosity, sport, lunacy, sex, ego and/or pleasure.
Related material





